Phim và Hoạt ảnh

Bohemian Rhapsody's Terrible Editing - A Breakdown

Use my link www.audible.com/thomasflight or text THOMASFLIGHT to 500-500 to get a free Audiobook, two Audible Originals, and a 30-day free trial.
Bohemian Rhapsody won the Oscar for Best Editing... but it has terrible editing.
// My patreon: www.patreon.com/thomasflight
// Music licensed from Musicbed: share.mscbd.fm/thomasflight
// TWITTER: twitter.com/thomasflight
// WEBSITE: www.thomasflight.com
// FACEBOOK: facebook.com/thomasflight
// I edit my videos using Premiere Pro: amzn.to/2FJwU2u
// For Sponsorship and Business inquiries: me@thomasflight.com

NHẬN XÉT

  1. shamefulshelf 75

    shamefulshelf 75

    9 phút trước

    Fake

  2. Alex

    Alex

    17 phút trước

    The shot of the chair...

  3. Domen Furar

    Domen Furar

    36 phút trước

    HEY! WHAT terrible editing?! It's the most perfect song, you fucOOHHHHHHH, you mean the movie. Carry on.

  4. Corey Fellows

    Corey Fellows

    44 phút trước

    How many Grammy nominations has this guy gotten for his work!!!

  5. DEADEYE214 Fortnite and apex player

    DEADEYE214 Fortnite and apex player

    51 phút trước

    I hate how they just randomly cut to each character

  6. Ultraviolence

    Ultraviolence

    53 phút trước

    *LITTLE FINGER*

  7. Charles Bartlett

    Charles Bartlett

    Giờ trước

    The film is dreadful

  8. mightyjoykiller

    mightyjoykiller

    2 giờ trước

    I still do not understand, why is mediocrity rewarded?

  9. Beren Gamble

    Beren Gamble

    2 giờ trước

    Apparently one scene means the rest of the movie is just as badly edited????

  10. Muge .Oskay

    Muge .Oskay

    2 giờ trước

    Horrible movie, great video. Producing by band members became disastrous for the movie, the script and the edit just forced to include the other members so poorly

  11. Lime Twist Animations

    Lime Twist Animations

    3 giờ trước

    I didn't mind it. But interesting to know at least.

  12. Normis

    Normis

    4 giờ trước

    I think that one mistake is to think that slower and calmer equals bad. It seems that Hollywood think that making everything hyper, frenetic and quick paced is immediately considered as better. You’re right about the reason why the movie won the Oscar, great video!

  13. Guccicurry

    Guccicurry

    5 giờ trước

    Its baffles me how people claim this is the best movie of 2018, i think its a pretty bland film.

  14. lovely A

    lovely A

    6 giờ trước

    I feel like I'm the only one that didnt like this movie. The story felt incredibly rushed, and too focused on freddie's sexuality which I don't mind but if they are making a movie about Queen they should have focused more on the amazing creative process and abilities they all had. Freddie himself always said he wasnt the 'leader' of the band but the singer and in this film they made it look the opposite way. I feel like the interpetation of Freddie was very exagerated and made him look like a very over the top arrogant man when in real life he was a very chill laid back guy. I get this film was more about his personal life but as a biography it was also very incomplete. Either you show his life or the band's trayectory, not both at the same time because you will end up rusging the story and modifying it to fit your narrative.

    • Morten Aanstad

      Morten Aanstad

      Giờ trước

      Believe me, you're not alone on not liking this movie

  15. Katelynn Rogers

    Katelynn Rogers

    6 giờ trước

    I believe this is why I had a hard time enjoying the film. Everything else made me want to love the film desperately, but the pace threw me off entirely.

  16. Ryan Erb

    Ryan Erb

    6 giờ trước

    Movie was trash

  17. RedRebel8

    RedRebel8

    8 giờ trước

    Watch Brian May's eyes on the 0.13 mark on. Wtf

  18. Carlos Miguel Ugalde

    Carlos Miguel Ugalde

    9 giờ trước

    yeah the movie sucks in general. great video.

  19. Doc Holliday

    Doc Holliday

    9 giờ trước

    I have an additional variable, the director. If the editor knows what to do but the director comes in and micromanages the cut, that can also result in a problem. If the editing in the rest of the movie is passable with certain scenes standing out, that screams director intervention to me. It's likely that the director wanted more (no pun intended) direct control over these particular scenes because, to him, they were the most important.

  20. Hans Wishbowl

    Hans Wishbowl

    10 giờ trước

    💚💚🌟🌟💙💙❤️❤️💸🎁🎁🏘️🏘️⚡️🌼🌼 ⚡️💥💥🍀🍀💛💛 *Jesus Christ is the Son of God, who died and rose from the dead to Give us eternal life.* *He also promised to heal your body.* *This Is True Love!!! (Just ask Him)*

  21. Yih Tat Tan

    Yih Tat Tan

    10 giờ trước

    Where do you get such high quality clips of a recently released movie?

  22. kasih sayang

    kasih sayang

    12 giờ trước

    toni collette are better than rami malek. according to me. but you know oscar this year just really suck. right.

  23. kasih sayang

    kasih sayang

    13 giờ trước

    so much cut gimme headace & makes me tired actually.

  24. Lowrie Music

    Lowrie Music

    13 giờ trước

    Maybe not everything has to be 'by-the-book'? If it were, film would be very dull. I enjoyed the editing in this film. It made me feel that I was watching each band members perspective which is what I feel the point of the fast paced editing was for. Not only that, the scene you go on about is supposed to be tense. If you'd seen the film as a viewer as opposed to a critic you may have noticed that.

  25. meningherme

    meningherme

    14 giờ trước

    Couldny agree more. When I saw this movie I didnt feel connected at all, everything went by so fast..

  26. 25052647

    25052647

    15 giờ trước

    You explain this catastrophe better than I ever could.

  27. Melita Colombi

    Melita Colombi

    15 giờ trước

    Funny because I noticed how fast it went to all the band members as if they had to have equal time? I know little about editing but this was so obvious I assumed it had something to do with screen time. Great tutorial about editing. Learned a great deal, no idea it involved so much perspective and skill.

  28. House of hell

    House of hell

    15 giờ trước

    Great movie thou...

  29. Rishi Parashar

    Rishi Parashar

    16 giờ trước

    Thank you.

  30. Ayden Toh

    Ayden Toh

    17 giờ trước

    Them cutting the sound and skipping audio in the music just sounded awkward

  31. A. E.

    A. E.

    18 giờ trước

    If the Academy takes into consideration the complications during a movie's production when deciding who wins an Oscar, as some of you are suggesting occurred for BR's editing nomination, then they aren't doing their job which is to find the best artists in each category based on their art alone. Any other consideration than who is the best is charity and will inevitably lead to celebrating mediocrity (if the Oscar's don't already *coughs-Black-Panther-coughs*) It wouldn't fly in any other industry: "Joe Schmoe, I know you came fifteenth in our Marathon, but upon being informed that you girlfriend broke up with you the night before, we've decided to award you the first place win to compensate for your obvious emotional distress."

  32. The Neon Chimp Channel

    The Neon Chimp Channel

    19 giờ trước

    I'm one of the few people I know who hated this film. I watched it with my mother and she hated it too, but nearly everyone else I've spoken to about it thought it was amazing. I was mostly bothered by the factual inaccuracies and the fact that Freddie came across as unlikable (at least to me). I didn't go into it looking at the editing, but it felt like a bad made for TV movie rather than a big budget cinematic film. I wouldn't have even nominated it for any awards other than for the music, but then the music wasn't written for the film. A Star Is Born which was also a music based film and released around the same time was a much better film all round. The songs weren't as good as Queen's, but they weren't expected to be.

  33. xFenix A2x

    xFenix A2x

    20 giờ trước

    Breakdown THE WORST EDITING WHICH IS A STAR IS BORN!!!!

  34. ok

    ok

    20 giờ trước

    Thank you I knew I didn’t like the movie for some reason and I couldn’t put it into words. Don’t get me wrong, I did love the story and the actors but the movie was so weird for me idk. Anytime I say it wasn’t that good of a movie i get attacked tho so 🤷🏻‍♀️

  35. Crispy

    Crispy

    20 giờ trước

    Very well done. Great video.

  36. SkeletalSounds _

    SkeletalSounds _

    20 giờ trước

    Objective way of breaking down a subjective issue. Well done. And subbed

  37. Trevor Pacelli

    Trevor Pacelli

    21 giờ trước

    Wow! What a fantastic analysis on the issues of this film's editing! Keep up the great work!

  38. P E D R O

    P E D R O

    21 giờ trước

    Your criticism is void, period. Because this movie isn’t for white males, sis. So I’m not interested in what you have to say. This movie is for biracial queer transwomen born in the 90’s Only. That’s the tea hunty.

    • depressed walrus

      depressed walrus

      20 giờ trước

      Only 90's kids get this movie

  39. JEFF_K

    JEFF_K

    21 giờ trước

    This was very interesting. Very informative information for the lay person regarding editing. So Bohemian Rhapsody is the Bourne Ultimatum Musical?

  40. Jon Dunmore

    Jon Dunmore

    21 giờ trước

    BOHEMIAN RHAPSODY should not have won ANY Oscars. That being said, excellent comprehensive critique of the editing!

  41. Mr. JustAGuyWithALightsaber

    Mr. JustAGuyWithALightsaber

    22 giờ trước

    It looks fine to me.

  42. El Búnker Del Mojón

    El Búnker Del Mojón

    22 giờ trước

    Rami Malek: the right guy in the wrong place

  43. Riccardo Alcaro

    Riccardo Alcaro

    22 giờ trước

    Bohemian rhapsody is just a very bad movie. A pity most people will remember the flat version of Freddie Mercury and the Queen from the movie rather than the real thing

  44. Jennifer Alex Oliveira

    Jennifer Alex Oliveira

    22 giờ trước

    www.bbc.com/news/entertainment-arts-47623796 educate yourselves, please. Taking into account what happened, and the Academy most likely knew this, he did pull it off. And what's more, you don't not deserve an Oscar because of one scene. And that's all you, and everyone, can focus on. A single scene.

    • depressed walrus

      depressed walrus

      20 giờ trước

      Here's the thing, there are movies that had great editing all through the movie, this movie doesn't have that

  45. PeaTearGryfin

    PeaTearGryfin

    22 giờ trước

    Bohemian Rhapsody is edited like a B-movie where they can't get two actors on set at the same time... except everybody is very clearly on the same set.

  46. Cal Studios

    Cal Studios

    22 giờ trước

    The ad that played before this had a Queen song in it

  47. VeganRevolution

    VeganRevolution

    22 giờ trước

    Great breakdown thanks

  48. even now, still i think

    even now, still i think

    23 giờ trước

    bohemian rhapsody, from the very start, was more of an attempt to appeal to wrong generation redditors than people who are actually interested in the story of queen

    • depressed walrus

      depressed walrus

      20 giờ trước

      Nah, I'm a redditor and I tough the movie was shite

  49. Subzero

    Subzero

    23 giờ trước

    And i thought i was stupid thinking the editing was so bad 😂

  50. yosoyalbertico

    yosoyalbertico

    23 giờ trước

    Totally agree

  51. Mau365PP

    Mau365PP

    23 giờ trước

    I haven't notice this until I saw this video

  52. Erica Simpson

    Erica Simpson

    Ngày trước

    Why is jarring bad? What if the discontinuity was a creative choice?

    • Erica Simpson

      Erica Simpson

      18 giờ trước

      depressed walrus just because it doesn’t work for you or OP doesn’t mean it doesn’t work for anyone

    • Erica Simpson

      Erica Simpson

      18 giờ trước

      depressed walrus discontinuity isn’t shit tho. I’m asking what if it’s ISNT shit and it was intentional. Many art films use disjunctive editing for a jarring effect. I guess mainstream cinema isn’t ready for that yet. I mean the creator should know better that the academy doesn’t actually mean anything and most of their awards are very evaluative rather than objective.

    • depressed walrus

      depressed walrus

      20 giờ trước

      You seriously saying the editing was shit because of "creative choice", that's just stupid

  53. rypulliam

    rypulliam

    Ngày trước

    There were so many damn montages in this movie I could not believe that it got nominated in the first place and then I came to discover that Bryan Singer is the director AKA sexual predator so then on top of that it just made me like the movie even less although Rami Malek did deliver a really good performance.

  54. Gemma Sutton

    Gemma Sutton

    Ngày trước

    I didn’t notice this when I watched it but now i can’t unsee it

  55. HD Pirat

    HD Pirat

    Ngày trước

    I rlly like this movie, I like it a lot tbh. But I did notice the edits and their abundance

  56. reuben champion

    reuben champion

    Ngày trước

    The pacing for that first scene you talk about is to make you feel awkward and uncomfortable. So they work great for the intended purpose.

  57. Brown Boy

    Brown Boy

    Ngày trước

    oscar milgya use ab apni gaand mraate rho

  58. Roxane

    Roxane

    Ngày trước

    The editing is flawed but I feel like some people totally overract about it...having a seizure every scene...lol you did not like it, it's fine but stop being so dramatic and over the top. It would not have been that popular if it was so unwatchable 🙄 I know many people who watched in several times in cinema.

    • Roxane

      Roxane

      15 giờ trước

      +depressed walrus And? Get over it, it's done.

    • depressed walrus

      depressed walrus

      20 giờ trước

      Still, not worthy of a oscar

  59. sober leech

    sober leech

    Ngày trước

    So many great points and very well put together (unlike this overrated crap we're discussing here; also, editing is not the only problem here, far from it). My respect.

  60. Rees Cullen

    Rees Cullen

    Ngày trước

    Just because they change the view doesn’t make it bad editing even if it is quite constant

  61. Austin G.

    Austin G.

    Ngày trước

    I'm glad I'm not the only one who thought the pacing was insanely bad until the part where Mary calls Freddie out for his sexuality. Then it kind of stabilizes from there somewhat, but the first 30 minutes are just campy and overly dramatic without any real emotional gravity to go with it until the aforementioned scene. It's almost like watching two different movies. It views kind of like "this happened, and then this happened, and then this happened, and then this happened, and then this happened", and then it slows down a bit and packs more of a punch. Overall, it was a good (albeit inaccurate) movie.

  62. flowertales

    flowertales

    Ngày trước

    this scene gives me motion sickness... i wish i were kidding

  63. Knox Productions

    Knox Productions

    Ngày trước

    So in your professional opinion as a leading, experienced, skilled editor, you think it's bad editing. Actually you've just made a statement, a hard statement of fact, not an opinion. But it won one of the most prestigious awards for editing! And everything you learned about the 'rules' of editing from film school and late night google holes about how best to make a film is broken and not used. Why? Because art doesn't follow your rules. How many rules of film-making does Pulp Fiction follow? Because it broke them all at the time. AND the editor did it without a director. I hope one day people realise your brilliance as a 'visual essay writer' and subsequently judge art based on your opinion.

  64. some short asian

    some short asian

    Ngày trước

    y can't ppl just enjoy movies anymore? y pick it apart sm that ppl that like it resent it. and honestly-none of this stuff stood out to me that much so...

    • some short asian

      some short asian

      33 phút trước

      +depressed walrus but i mean let's be real, i'm not paying attention to how many cuts are in a movie, like, just watch the movie.

    • depressed walrus

      depressed walrus

      20 giờ trước

      Because it won an Oscar

  65. Buuzzsaw Touched Me

    Buuzzsaw Touched Me

    Ngày trước

    I thought the timeline for this film was all wrong. Because if your a Die Hard Queen like (such as myself) you keep on expecting certain events to happen, where they don't. An alternatively if your just the Casual fan (which is who this film was made for) due to what was missing from the film, I can see why it would confuse them too (such as Freddie's realisation of being Gay/Bi and/or the development of his relationship with Jim Hutton, as with Jim Hutton your never sure whether they are/aren't together). Then most importantly, music wise it doesn't show the climb they went through pre-1st album, as Freddie just randomly says in the film while fixing the Van "let's sell the Van and use that money to record an album", an it just doesn't work like that (maybe these days, but not back then).

  66. BJ EV

    BJ EV

    Ngày trước

    Terribly good jajajaja

  67. RACine Filmagens - Films & Videos

    RACine Filmagens - Films & Videos

    Ngày trước

    Talk is cheap.

  68. Edgy

    Edgy

    Ngày trước

    I liked this scene but I also know nothing about editing so take this as someone who knows nothing about music saying they like modern pop music.

  69. TheJaybrone

    TheJaybrone

    Ngày trước

    I think the editing issues came in large part due to a director that basically disappeared as the movie was close to wrapping. But it is definitely not well edited and had 0 business winning for it.

  70. Itami Kuroitsuki

    Itami Kuroitsuki

    Ngày trước

    sO ThIS iS QuEen ?

  71. Shawn DeJesus

    Shawn DeJesus

    Ngày trước

    Academy Awards have to be a joke by now.

  72. keyda castaño

    keyda castaño

    Ngày trước

    This movie won vedt musical editing

  73. Quipt Training

    Quipt Training

    Ngày trước

    Lol I was just about to bring up the transformers movies, they make cuts every 2 seconds and it triggers my anxiety.

  74. Caroline Klemensová

    Caroline Klemensová

    Ngày trước

    I'm way far from being a film critic but even I noticed the bad editing when watching this movie..

  75. FineCrafters

    FineCrafters

    Ngày trước

    Why can’t people just appreciate this film for who it’s about

  76. Mr Me

    Mr Me

    Ngày trước

    Blah blah blah the movie was great. Find something better to make videos about pedantic dude.

    • depressed walrus

      depressed walrus

      20 giờ trước

      Why shouldn't he make the video?

  77. Cassandre Cendre

    Cassandre Cendre

    Ngày trước

    A movie for those who discovered Queen in 2018.

  78. Chuck Buskee

    Chuck Buskee

    Ngày trước

    I think it won because all of those transition cuts into a song or performance scene, those were pretty cool. But yeah, in general the editing was pure shit.

  79. John Baumgartner

    John Baumgartner

    Ngày trước

    Quick aside, Walter Murch was not the editor of GODFATHER, though he had a big influence on the sound design

  80. Aesthetical Twat

    Aesthetical Twat

    Ngày trước

    I was happy watching it, and that’s the most important thing.

  81. Ema With A Tee

    Ema With A Tee

    Ngày trước

    Watching the scenes cut is like being hit by a hammer while also having whiplash. Maybe it's just because I'm tired, but it's almost impossible to watch

  82. Cahal Doherty

    Cahal Doherty

    Ngày trước

    great film guy was tiny compared to freddy thk like really jarred me

  83. SANTA IS AMAZING MUGHEAD

    SANTA IS AMAZING MUGHEAD

    Ngày trước

    Actually that doesn’t bother that much you said .

  84. tequilex rook

    tequilex rook

    Ngày trước

    I'm feeling dizzy right now after watching this

  85. A Conneely

    A Conneely

    Ngày trước

    If I get your Free Audiobook will I learn how to win an Oscar ?

  86. Im Bored

    Im Bored

    Ngày trước

    yeah the bad editing is incredibly clear in the climax of the film, where the music drops the camera will have anti climatic shots like a side view of rami or of the crowd

  87. wesley Phillip

    wesley Phillip

    Ngày trước

    gr8; my FB comment was that the film is an overblown video ... however I don't think it was aimed at people like me (60+).

  88. AJ King

    AJ King

    Ngày trước

    Paid by the cut!

  89. Tommy Nico

    Tommy Nico

    Ngày trước

    I seriously don't understand why it got so many accolades. As you stated the editing is quite poor in places but I found some of the acting and dialogue just absolutely dreadful. It's so cringe in places. Rami Malek was great....however everything else wasn't. It's infuriating when people say it's one of the greatest films of the last 10-20 years. I mean come on.

  90. Heven demo

    Heven demo

    Ngày trước

    Is it weird that I find that it fits the image of queen because its unconventional like they were?

  91. 宋少閑 。

    宋少閑 。

    Ngày trước

    A great film with tons of cuts that won best editing is JFK

    • Morten Aanstad

      Morten Aanstad

      Giờ trước

      Yeah. I don't even care about those conspiracy theories, and I was still blown away by how the music and editing made something as dull as formal talking actually feel intense and suspenseful

  92. Frost Byte

    Frost Byte

    Ngày trước

    9:57 Hits the uncanny valley for me, look like cgi

  93. jules giddings

    jules giddings

    Ngày trước

    If the editing was so bad, why did the editor get an oscar?

    • depressed walrus

      depressed walrus

      20 giờ trước

      Because the Oscars are a joke

  94. Ryan C. Reed

    Ryan C. Reed

    Ngày trước

    Was stylized this way on purpose. The fact that you made this video is proof you’ve missed the point entirely. It’s why you’re making VNchannel videos instead of feature films earning Oscars.

    • Morten Aanstad

      Morten Aanstad

      Giờ trước

      +Ryan C. Reed With your twisted and pedantic philosophy, one could punch a guy and then say in court "Hey, it's your opinion that it's wrong to punch a guy". Or how about an examiner grading a paper to a D and the student says "Hey, I should get an A since the way I wrote it is how I wanted to express it and I love it, and you only gave me an D because you didn't like it. You should have no right to criticize the paper since it's all subjective"? Or how about some tone-deaf Idol contestant who gets panned by Simon Cowell before saying "This is how I intended to sing, and you should not judge me since art is subjective. You only judged me because you didn't like it, and you shouldn't judge me like there's a correct way to sing"? Also, if an artist creates something that 99.9% of the world population think is shit and he says "You just don't understand how I intended it", then that person would just be viewed as pedantic and delusional. It also doesn't matter what an artist intends if 99.9% of the audience doesn't see how it's reflected in the final product. Anyone who knows anything about art knows that the practice is based on conventions in society and how the artist communicates with the audience.

    • Ryan C. Reed

      Ryan C. Reed

      20 giờ trước

      +depressed walrus I'm indifferent on the editing honestly. I respect the choice they made. It's how they chose to express their art style. Original point however was it was on purpose and definitely not an accident. Clearly you don't like it and that's your choice. Just feel that art and style is more subjective. People either can hate it or love it. I don't feel there is a right answer on this, other than the artists choice to make it what they made. Just is what it is. I don't really feel it deserves a lengthy editing example on how things SHOULD be edited as there is no RIGHT way to edit. It's completely subjective and really not open to a right and wrong way. Then correct way is what the artist intended it should be. Like I said . Either you get it or you don't. Certain styles and artistic choices are not for everyone.

    • depressed walrus

      depressed walrus

      20 giờ trước

      +Ryan C. Reed OK them, I just don't understand how people liked this editing, I was nauseous at the end of the movie and seeing people prasing it just doesn't make sense for me

    • Ryan C. Reed

      Ryan C. Reed

      20 giờ trước

      +depressed walrus Ha yes. Definitely not everyone's cup of tea. Still though style is a matter of perspective. The beauty is the folks that get it - get it - and those that don't - don't and that's alright too. But the editing style was absolutely a choice and done on purpose. Was not an accident or a matter of sloppy editing. Either you like it or you don't.

    • depressed walrus

      depressed walrus

      20 giờ trước

      What's "the point" then? Make you nauseous?

  95. Loga Padmanaba

    Loga Padmanaba

    Ngày trước

    I had felt that something was off in this scene. It's good to know what actually it was...

  96. Mtwarrior

    Mtwarrior

    Ngày trước

    so this is queen

  97. markdabomb 64

    markdabomb 64

    Ngày trước

    The John Reid scene should of been that when he says "So, this is Queen" We should of got a shot of the whole band then an individual shot of each member This would of given them equal credit of being a member

  98. Daisy B

    Daisy B

    Ngày trước

    Idk if this is because I'm a huge queen stan and like soooo far up each of the BoRhap boys arses but I never really realised the editing lmao, I guess it just comes down to preferences?¿

  99. Grr Kpp

    Grr Kpp

    Ngày trước

    Good perspective

  100. Grr Kpp

    Grr Kpp

    Ngày trước

    Wtf!

Tiếp theo